On the one hand there's CNBC, well known for its cheer-leading and Pollyanna optimism, and the equally cheerful CNN.com. CNN quotes experts who believe many stocks are "bargains" that will soon attract buying, that "global imbalances are getting corrected," and that the selloff in stocks is encouraging.
And then, on the other hand, there's this piece in the UK Telegraph:
We face extreme danger. Unless there is immediate intervention on every front
by all the major powers acting in concert, we risk a disintegration of
global finance within days. Nobody will be spared, unless they own gold bars.
. . .
During the past week, we have tipped over the edge, into the middle of the
abyss. Systemic collapse is in full train. The Netherlands has just rushed
through a second, more sweeping nationalisation of Fortis. Ireland and
Greece have had to rescue all their banks. Iceland is facing an Argentine
denouement.
The US commercial paper market is closed. It shrank $95bn last week, and has
lost $208bn in three weeks. The interbank lending market has seized up.
There are almost no bids. It is a ghost market. Healthy companies cannot
roll over debt. Some will have to sack staff today to stave off default.
As the unflappable Warren Buffett puts it, the credit freeze is “sucking
blood” out of the economy. “In my adult lifetime, I don’t think I’ve ever
seen people as fearful,” he said.
We are fast approaching the point of no return. The only way out of this
calamitous descent is “shock and awe” on a global scale, and even that may
not be enough.
In the less mainstream media, the guy who founded the popular website 321gold.com is predicting a bank holiday very soon. [Note that this is separate from the rumor about Bank of America preparing for a one-week holiday.] Bob Moriarty was interviewed on the Korelin Economics Report on Saturday, and I've roughly transcribed the relevant bits:
Bob Moriarty: The banking system is frozen... banks simply will not loan to each other. We are a few days away from a bank holiday. The banks will either have a run on the banks, or the government will step in and close all the banks down. It will go worldwide within 24 hours....
Now the bank holiday gets extremely dangerous because most Americans don't have two days' food and don't have two days' money. So, unless the government starts coming up with real solutions real quick, we could have a total catastrophe.
Al Korelin: Okay, now what about those folks-- and you talk about a bank holiday-- what about the folks... that utilize debit cards -- not credit cards, debit cards -- as opposed to currency? Are they out of luck?
Bob Moriarty: I think those will be frozen too. I think that if you go down to your ATM, if you have a debit card, if you have a credit card, [they will not work].... This is it! I mean if you don't have some gold, if you don't have some spare cash handy, you're gonna have a problem.
Al Korelin: Do you think credit cards are going to be frozen too?
Bob Moriarty: Yes.
Al Korelin: You do. If that happens, things are going to be more than just a little bit ugly. And you're giving it what kind of a probability, Bob?
Bob Moriarty: Something above 95%, within the next 10 days.
Al Korelin: How long do you think that crisis would last?
Bob Moriarty: And again-- that's a really good question. It's gonna last until the government comes up with a real solution.
Oh good, I'm sure the government will handle things nicely and we'll all get back to normal by the next morning, eh? Oy vey.
Another well-known trader and commentator, Jim Sinclair, had this to say last Thursday:
Dear Extended Family,
Unless the LIBOR rate drops sharply we are facing a planetary financial crisis next week.
For God's sake protect yourself.
Gold and gold related items will be the
only true storehouses of wealth. The bailout bill is powerless to
reverse what is now happening.
This is a modern day Weimar happening right before our eyes.
Respectfully yours,
Jim
The LIBOR is the London Inter-Bank Offered Rate, meaning the interest rate that one bank charges another bank which needs to borrow some quick cash. When the interest rate goes way up, it's because banks do not want to lend to each other. When the LIBOR is very high, it indicates a freeze-up, where funds don't move around, no one can get credit, loans are nearly nonexistent. The LIBOR came down a tiny smidge today, but is still very close to its all-time high, set last week. Money is not moving.
Consider for a moment what it means when a small company cannot get a short-term loan for a few months or a year. Suppose you're a large bakery and you buy your wheat just once in the fall, using credit. Or suppose you own a grain elevator and fill it up in the fall, then make back the money as you sell grain over the course of the next year. Or suppose you do 70% of your retail business in the Christmas season and you need to order a huge amount of merchandise right about now, using credit.
By and large, you can't do it. Often, no one will give you the credit. Just as homeowners have lost their home equity lines, businesses have lost their commercial loans. The owner of a grain elevator near my parents actually had this happen to him. He couldn't fill his giant silos with corn and wheat, even though he has gotten an autumn loan from the same bank for decades, and never once been late on a payment. He was forced to sell his business due to lack of funding. I also heard an anecdote about grocery chains in southern California not being able to place large orders for food items, which, if things got bad enough, could lead to empty shelves.
Now imagine that a state-- say, California-- used to be able to borrow money, partly through what used to be called the municipal bonds market (may it rest in peace). Now they can't. How do they make payroll? Well... they beg and plead with Hanky Panky Paulson to spend a mere $7 billion rescuing the largest state economy in the country. You would think Hank would've already come through for them-- after all, the Fed gives $250 billion to US and foreign banks every single day, so what's $7 billion? (No, I didn't type that wrong. It's well over a trillion a week they give to banks.)
It looks pretty dire to me. I am inclined to believe the people in the "gloom and doom" camp, rather than the smiling sexpots on CNBC.
After all, the reporting in 1929 was all very reassuring. Here's a snippet from a November 1, 1929 New York Times article titled "British Foresee Benefits in Crash":
LONDON, Nov. 1 -- The material prosperity of the United States is too firmly based, in the opinion of The Economist, one of the foremost economic journals in England, for a revival of industrial activity to be long delayed.
Here's another from the same day, titled "Sees Prosperity Unhurt":
Stuart Chase, economist, who completed recently a six-month survey of the structure of prosperity in the United States, said here yesterday that the present stock market will not affect the prosperity of the country.
There are other well-known quotes from the time, in which the famous or the erudite claimed that everything was just fine. Maybe it's unfair to hold the ignorance and poor predictive ability of the mainstream media of 1929 against the mainstream media of today, but it tends to make me side with the doom and gloomers. It might not be as bad as they say, but it doesn't have to get THAT bad before a lot of people will suffer.
In short, if you aren't scared, you don't understand what's happening.